What is “The Appraisal Clause” in Vehicle Accident Insurance Claims!

The Appraisal Process In Plain Terms

Even when an insurance company agrees to cover a claim, disagreements often pop up over how much that claim is actually worth, especially in vehicle diminished value and vehicle total loss cases. When that happens, it’s worth considering whether the issue can be resolved through an appraisal process before heading into expensive, time-consuming litigation.

Most vehicle insurance policies include an appraisal clause. It’s an alternative dispute resolution method either side can trigger if there’s agreement on what is covered, but not how much it’s worth. It’s important to know that appraisal is not the place to fight over policy language or coverage details. Those questions belong in court. Appraisal is strictly about settling the value of a covered loss.

That said, if the value dispute hinges on interpreting the policy itself, then appraisal may not be the right route. But in plenty of cases, the fight is simply over the numbers, and in those cases, appraisal might be the most efficient way to move forward.

How It Works

Each side, the policyholder and the insurer, picks a qualified, impartial appraiser. These two appraisers work independently to come up with a value. If they agree, that’s the final number. If not, they bring in a neutral umpire, who then becomes the dead lock breaker.  Everyone pays their own appraiser, and the two sides split the cost of the umpire.

Why Appraisal Can Be a Smart Move

Appraisal can be faster, cheaper, and less combative than going to court. If the dispute is really about valuations, then appraisal helps avoid drawn-out discovery, depositions, and trial.  It also gives the policyholder a chance to bring in an expert appraiser who understands the specifics of the loss and can present a well-documented, high-value case.

Here are a few more things to keep in mind:

• Appraisal decisions are final. Once signed, it’s binding, and very hard to overturn. Nobody should sign unless in agreement and, if none is found, court is always a next option.
• It’s not always faster. Finding two appraisers and an umpire can take time, sometimes months.
• Neutrality can be tough. Appraisers with experience on the policyholder side are harder to find, and many umpires are more familiar with insurance company practices.

Bottom line: appraisal can be a useful tool when the dispute is truly about how much something is worth.  but it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Any policyholder considering it should consult with experienced advisors to understand the pros, the cons, and the stakes.